Decision near at second base? Just part of the intrigue

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — It was tempting to derive significance from Emmanuel Burriss’ second consecutive start at second base on Sunday. Previously, Giants manager Bruce Bochy had alternated Burriss and Kevin Frandsen day by day, virtually without fail.

But Bochy declined to say that this meant Burriss, who’s hitting .362, had won the second base tug-of-war with Frandsen, who’s batting .286.

Asked if anything should be read into Burriss’ back-to-back starts, Bochy replied, “Right now, no. I knew with (Pablo) Sandoval down (with a mild left ankle injury) that I was going to split the game at third. Instead of moving Franny from second to third, I was going to give him the back half of the game there.” Frandsen replaced Rich Aurilia, who started his second game of the spring at third base, in the fifth inning.

Still, the Giants’ apparent interest in seeing what Frandsen can do at other positions creates the appearance that Burriss will secure the second base job. If it’s any comfort to Frandsen’s faithful legion of fans, he’d still have a good chance to make the Opening Day roster as a reserve.

The returns of Keiichi Yabu and Ramon Ortiz from Minor League camp constituted another intriguing development. Installing a long reliever in the bullpen would make it easier for the Giants to open the season with an 11-man pitching staff (and keep an additional deserving position player on the roster, such as Frandsen, Andres Torres or Eugenio Velez). The Giants have experimented with their existing bullpen candidates by using them in multiple-inning stints. But Yabu, who often pitched in long relief last year for the Giants, and Ortiz, a former starter, could be better-suited for the role than anyone remaining in big league camp.

Bochy didn’t hide the Giants’ intentions while indicating that either Yabu, who yielded the game’s only run on Richie Weeks’ fifth-inning homer, or Ortiz could return.

“We’re staying open-minded here,” Bochy said. “… It (recalling players during Spring Training who have been sent to the Minors) is not unusual at all. We tell these guys that when you go down there, you’re not out of the picture. If we have the opportunity, we’ll bring you back. They’ve been doing what they need to be doing, and that’s throw the ball well down there.”

This final item isn’t controversial, Earth-shaking or intriguing at all. Just worth mentioning. Giants first baseman Travis Ishikawa turned in probably the club’s finest defensive play of the spring when he hurled himself to his right, snared Mike Lamb’s grounder and righted himself in time to flip the ball to Yabu covering first for the out.

Ishikawa looked like the reincarnation of J.T. Snow.

“That’s a highlight play right there,” Bochy said.

Ishikawa, a genuinely modest individual, couldn’t hide his delight.

“Those are the kind that you dream about, feeling like you get full extension and completing the play,” he said. “Offensively, I might not always be there, but (I’ll be) giving my all on defense as well.”

At various times this spring, Ishikawa has benefited from the tutelage of Snow and Will Clark, who made first base the glamorous position that it was when Orlando Cepeda and Willie McCovey roamed the bag (and the batter’s box) for the Giants. 

“You’ve got two of the better first basemen who ever played,” Ishikawa said, referring to Clark and Snow. “What better first baseman’s dream is that? Two Gold Glove-winning first basemen working with you — it doesn’t get better than that.”

— Chris Haft



Did I miss something? There was a report, and it’s still in the transactions, that Yabu was released on 3-19. Now I read that he’s still here. What’s up? Is he on the roster or not. If he was released, was he re-signed as a minor leaguer?

Nothing against Burriss, but I just think the team’s future is with Frandsen at second. He’s my Jeff Kent clone and I’m just looking forward to watching him play on a regular basis. I would have loved to see the Giants go with Burriss at short instead of signing “washed up” Renteria. As many youngsters as we watched last year, I was thinking that was the route we we going as a team (going with youth). All I see is positives going with Burriss at short and Frandsen at second. We saw what Frandsen could do when playing regularly at the end of the 2007 season and so my expectations for him are still the same. I’m willing to wait and watch Burriss develop into an excellent defensive shortstop. I’ll also wait for him to come around in the hitting department. Anything he does with the bat will be better than what we had with Vizquel.

We signed Renteria because Burriss failed to show he could handle playing shortstop everyday in the arizona fall league. i hope they stick with the plan and let burriss devolope into the everyday SS over the next two years and eventually have that burriss-frandsen middle infield. That being said I’ve been pulling for burriss to win the job this spring. Frandsen showed us one good month, Burriss showed us a good whole year. I hope he gets the job he really stepped up to the plate and impressed last year.

Frandsen has shown to be a reliable fielder and hitter at the , level. Burriss out-hit and out-fielded him all spring, and also offers speed and good baserunning as a bonus. If this was a fair competition for the starting 2B position, then Burriss won it hands down. The idea that he could be the future Giants SS just verifies that he’s a superior fielder to Frandsen, and shouldn’t indicate that his spring performance was anything less than outstanding. As for Yabu, I was so thrilled with his release, nearly as thrilled as when Taschner was traded, and now, please Sabes, don’t trot this guy out there again in 2009, please?

congrats for being the top overall MLBlog from Saturday through right now, by a wide margin…wondering if any visitors here can let me know on the community blog at where the spike in page views might have come from (besides you just being a fabulous blogger!). was it related to sandoval injury? extra promo somewhere? something significant happened and just exploring (then keep doing it lol). thanks,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: